Homily on the Gospel Reading from Matthew 9:9–13
By Bishop Maximos Pafilis of Melitene
Above the cobblestones of the marketplace, the words of Jesus to Matthew are heard. The reverberation of this address may be nothing more than a simple whisper, yet it is capable of rearranging the particles of an entire life, that is, of an existence that had been forbidden to calculate the debts of others.
Matthew, seated at the tax office, the throne of his personal shame and public alienation, rises from his place and immediately follows Him.
This happened simply and solely because the voice that came to him saw the hidden corners of his soul, his human nature that thirsted for something beyond price and exchange.
And immediately then, the scandal is born: the table, the closeness, the Master's gathering together with sinners.
Standing on the sidelines of this scene, however, are the Pharisees, the observers, that is, the eternal condemners of grace, wrapped in the sterile covering of their own certainty.
They perceive only the filth, the contamination of association, the fact that holiness is being shared so unreservedly with the unclean, with sinners.
The banquet, the unbearable proximity of the Sacred to the profane, causes them to recoil, as they whisper to the disciples the question that poisons every expectation of encounter: “Why does your Teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?” (Matthew 9:11).
At this very point of perplexity, in their firm refusal to grasp the economy of love, we too belong, trapped in the meticulous calculation of our reputation. The very thought of sitting on the dirty sidewalk, touching the pain of a homeless person, or listening to the silent anguish of an abused woman terrifies us.
Above all, we tremble at the fear of being given a bad name, that is, those malicious “brotherly” tongues, the meticulous guardians of outward purity, who will tear us to pieces.
The fear of the label, the suspicion, the association, emerges as our true prison.
The criticism of others seems to be the monotonous sound of a hammer that ultimately seals our spirit inside the rotten coffin of hypocrisy.
The consolidation of respectable gatherings is our choice: those social or religious meetings where our presence is counted as a virtue.
Our piety is fully validated by our surroundings, while our distance from raw, real suffering remains assured.
With meticulous care, we turn our backs precisely at the point where the need for Christ's love constitutes an open, festering wound.
There, our silence allows invisibility to continue its work. We become experts in theological terminology, yet remain beginners in the mercy that soils our hands.
The call, however, is addressed exclusively to the sick who recognize their fever, passing over the theoreticians of health.
It is a surgical operation, that is, the moment when the Physician identifies the disease and offers the cure, going beyond the limits of a comfortable invitation to a social event.
This particular call, as Saint John Chrysostom insists, has a specific content and purpose: “For I have not come, He says, to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance—not to laughter, but to tears.”[1]
This call, we would certainly say, concerns the recognition of the wound and the breaking of the mask, demanding something deeper, more substantial, and beyond our polished shoes and expensive clothes.
We live on this double stage, anxiously striving to keep our “good name” intact. And the hours, the years granted to us by God pass and disappear like empty, black shells, creaking beneath the wheel of death, which draws ever closer.
We choose entirely the hypocritical life, the convenient shell, the respectable silence, and the good food.
Our hiding place, however, is merely a beautifully decorated tomb, within which the immortal voice of love has been buried forever.
We keep the joy of Christ for ourselves, taking care, out of fear, that it should not be revealed, misinterpreted, or soiled through contact with the world.
This joy, however, I am certain, when it remains undistributed, becomes a rusty key that unlocks the chamber of self-condemnation.
We convince ourselves that we are the healthy ones, the “strong,” those who believe they need nothing, and thus our final breath becomes a trembling bridge of time connecting the decay of our “good name” with an eternity left unused.
This Physician, the Lord, defined His mission with absolute clarity: “Those who are strong have no need of a physician, but those who are sick” (Matthew 9:12).
He approaches the sick. And, in order to leave no room for doubt about His method, He adds the terrifying declaration addressed to the Pharisees: “But go and learn what this means: I desire mercy and not sacrifice” (Matthew 9:13).
He seeks mercy. Our own sacrifice, however, consists of a performance, an outward achievement, a theater of piety, while the mercy of Christ demands the incomprehensible, difficult, and untidy recognition of our common illness, our common brokenness.
There is something profoundly paradoxical and terrifying that we see every day in our lives, or, even worse, put into practice ourselves.
Those who have the greatest need of the Physician are often those who maintain absolute confidence in their own health.
They believe that they possess authority over the truth, having built an impenetrable moral life, and regard others with revulsion or pity.
The deception of moralism is a diamond fashioned from infected blood, which reflects only the fear of the revelation of the truth.
Their certainty, this sole certainty, is the disease itself. Their “righteousness” emerges as the greatest obstacle.
They wear Pharisaic garments, expensive, beautiful, and carefully ironed, but these fabrics are costly, ceremonial chains that suffocate the flesh of what is essential...
The self-diagnosis of health constitutes the fatal error, since it functions as an anesthetic that stops the pain and guarantees necrosis. Perhaps the logic of salvation begins with the admission of the wound, just as Nikolaos Damalas observes in his analogy concerning the sufferer: “If someone considers himself healthy, he will certainly never seek a physician.”[2]
But perhaps you refuse the diagnosis and, consequently, the Physician, even though you sit in the front pews of the church?
It seems very difficult for you and me to show a willingness to sit at the table with the various Matthews of this world.
Perhaps this happens because their sin is visible and exposed, while ours is insulated behind deceptive silence, social acceptance, and theological terminology.
The Lord, however, let us not forget, entered the world for sinners.
There is no other truth. Only this one. It is harsh for us who have spent our lives trying precisely not to appear as sinners, focusing on our image rather than on what is essential.
We erected a fortress of virtue, and now we are being made aware that the very fortress will fall and crush our soul.
Christ stands and waits, waiting for us to confess that we live trapped within the very structures we erected for our protection, for our own good, which ultimately overshadow His glory.
The mystery of the “sinner's” banquet continues, whether it receives our approval or not. We will not be asked.
It unfolds in dark alleyways and wounded homes. On the dirty bench with the homeless person, on the sidewalk with the drug addict, in a cheap tavern with those whom respectable society casts out.
There will always be Matthews who accept the hand of Christ, no matter how derisively the modern Pharisees smile like well-dressed vipers.
Let us be patient; eventually, at our final breath, we shall all see that incontrovertible, supreme evaluation of our lives: how many times we dined with our respectable Pharisee brothers, and how many times we dined in the poor man's house with Christ and the “sinners.”
Notes:
[1] John Chrysostom, The Complete Works, in Patrologiae Cursus Completus: Series Graeca, ed. Jacques-Paul Migne, vol. 59 (Paris: J.-P. Migne, 1862), 566.
[2] Nikolaos M. Damalas, On the Scientific and Ecclesiastical Principles of Orthodox Theology (Leipzig: Otto Wigand Press, 1865), 127.
Source: Translated by John Sanidopoulos.
