
By Vladimir Lovyagin
In the inscription to the Apology, which scholars believe belongs to Athenagoras himself, he identifies himself as an Athenian and a Christian philosopher. Unfortunately, history has preserved no further details about the life of this apologist. Only two writers mention Athenagoras: Saint Methodios of Olympus (+ 311) and Philip of Side (+ 431). The former cites a passage from Athenagoras' Apology;* the latter said only a few words, which are highly questionable; Eusebius and Jerome remain silent about this writer.** Philip of Side remarks: "The head of the Alexandrian school was Athenagoras. He lived during the times of Hadrian and Antoninus, and presented his Apology in defense of Christians. He professed the Christian faith even at a time when he still donned the philosopher's toga and was a leader in the academy."
Intending to write against Christianity, in order to more surely achieve his goal, he commenced reading the holy books, and, captivated by the grace of the Holy Spirit, became a preacher of the very doctrine against which he had risen. His pupil was Clement of Alexandria, from whom Pantaenus learned. (See Dodvel. Dissertation on Irenaeus, at the end.) However, this is almost the only evidence, and much of it is contested, because in its private testimonies, it directly contradicts the account of the Church historian Eusebius, who lived before Philip and whose historical writings far surpass the meager compilation of Philip, which is poorly regarded according to the opinions of Socrates (Ecclesiastical History, Book 17, Chapter 27) and Patriarch Photios (Codex XXXV), and is grandly titled the History of Christianity. For instance, Philip incorrectly asserts that Athenagoras was the head of the Alexandrian school; for in that case, it is incomprehensible how the works of such a renowned figure could remain unknown even to Eusebius. Furthermore, Clement of Alexandria was not a teacher, but a student of Pantaenus, as clearly indicated by Eusebius (Ecclesiastical History, Book 5, Chapter 10) and Photios (Codex CIX).



