Commentary on the Book of the Prophet Obadiah
By Professor Alexander Pavlovich Lopukhin
By Professor Alexander Pavlovich Lopukhin
The Book of the Prophet Obadiah is the shortest work of Old Testament biblical literature. Its subject is a vision concerning Edom. The essence of this vision lies in the prediction of Edom’s destruction and the proclamation of salvation on Zion. The prophet hears that a messenger has already been sent to the nations, calling them to rise up and wage war against Edom (Obadiah 1:7). The prophet sees that Edom has already been brought low and held in contempt (Obadiah 1:2), laid waste and plundered—in spite of the inaccessibility of the rocks on which it is settled (Obadiah 1:3–6)—and even driven out to the border (Obadiah 1:7). Edom’s former allies have become its enemies (Obadiah 1:7); the wise men of Edom have been destroyed (Obadiah 1:8); its mighty men have been overcome with fear, and the entire people have been brought to destruction (Obadiah 1:9). The reason for such a severe attack on Edom is its crime against Judah, specifically its treacherous treatment of its brother nation on the day of its calamity (Obadiah 1:9–14). But Edom appears to the prophet not only as an enemy of Judah, but also as a representative of the pagan world hostile to God. Therefore, from judgment against Edom, the prophet turns to judgment against the entire pagan world (Obadiah 1:15–21). On the day of Judgment, according to the prophet’s description, all the nations “shall drink, swallow, and shall be as though they had never been” (Obadiah 1:16). The house of Esau, the Edomites, will then become like straw consumed by flame (Obadiah 1:18), while on Zion there will be salvation, and the house of Jacob will possess its inheritance (Obadiah 1:17, 19–20), and the Kingdom of the Lord will be established (Obadiah 1:21).
Nothing is reported about the person of the prophet Obadiah, either in his book or in the rest of biblical literature. Even the prophet’s name itself is regarded by some authors (Augustine, Küper) as merely a pseudonym rather than his actual name. There are, however, no serious grounds for this. But neither are there grounds for identifying Obadiah, the author of the prophetic book, with any other Obadiah mentioned in the Bible (4 Kingdoms 1:13; 2 Chronicles 17:7), or for accepting as reliable the contradictory accounts of Obadiah found in ancient literature.
It is very difficult to establish with certainty the time in which Obadiah lived and the date when his book originated, since the necessary evidence is lacking. In the absence of external testimony concerning the Book of Obadiah, the principal evidence ordinarily used to determine its date consists of: 1) the indications in Obadiah 1:10–14 concerning Edom’s treatment of Judah during the capture of Jerusalem by its enemies; and 2) the close similarity between Obadiah’s prophecy concerning Edom and Jeremiah’s prophecy concerning the same people (Jeremiah 49:7–22). These indications, however, can be interpreted in different ways. First, Jerusalem fell into the hands of its enemies on several occasions. Specifically, during the reign of Rehoboam (approximately 975–958), it was captured by the Egyptian Pharaoh Shishak (3 Kingdoms 14:26; 2 Chronicles 12:2–4, 9); during the reign of Jehoram (approximately 889–882), it was taken by the Philistines and Arabs (2 Chronicles 21:16–17); during the reign of Amaziah (approximately 839–811), by the Israelite king Joash (4 Kingdoms 14:13–17; 2 Chronicles 25:23–24); and during the reigns of Jehoiakim, Jehoiachin, and Zedekiah, the city was captured by the Babylonians (4 Kingdoms 24:1, 10–16; 2 Chronicles 36:6–7, 10; Daniel 1:1–4). Second, the relationship between the Book of Obadiah and the similar passage in Jeremiah 49 can be understood in different ways. Consequently, biblical scholarship offers widely differing opinions concerning the date of the Book of Obadiah. Some authors consider it the earliest prophetic work (Hoffmann, Orelli, Cornely, Jungerov), while others assign its origin to the period of the Exile and the post-Exilic period (the majority of more recent authors). Of these opinions, the one that connects Obadiah 1:10–14 with the capture of Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar appears to have the strongest grounds. The advantage of this view over the others is that it rests not on conjecture, but on clear biblical testimony. The participation of the Edomites in the capture of Jerusalem by the Chaldeans is noted in several places in the Bible and is described in precisely the same terms that are emphasized in Obadiah 1:10–14.
The prophet calls the calamity of Jerusalem that he has in mind the “day” of Judah, that is, a fateful day, a day of terrible catastrophe. According to the prophet’s description, Jerusalem had been brought to the utmost extremity, so that lots were already being cast over it (Obadiah 1:11). The fate that then befell Judah is the same fate that awaits all pagan nations on the day of Judgment, including Edom (Obadiah 1:15–16), namely, destruction. The prophet could have depicted only the conquest of Judea and Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar in these terms. Furthermore, the Prophet Ezekiel directly charged the Edomites with handing the children of Israel over to the sword “at the time of their calamity, at the time of their final destruction,” and with mocking them by saying of the mountains of Israel: “They are laid waste! They have been given to us for food!” (Ezekiel 35:5, 12). In Lamentations 4:21, the Edomites are charged with rejoicing and exulting over Judah’s misfortune: “Rejoice and be glad, O daughter of Edom, you who dwell in the land of Uz! The cup shall also come to you; you shall become drunk and expose yourself.” Finally, in Psalm 136, the Edomites’ attitude toward Judah’s calamity on the day Jerusalem was captured is described as follows: “Remember, O Lord, against the sons of Edom the day of Jerusalem, when they said: ‘Destroy it, destroy it, down to its foundations!’” The conduct of the Edomites during the conquest of Jerusalem is described in similar terms in Obadiah 1:10–14: “You should not have looked with malicious satisfaction—you should not have rejoiced over the children of Judah on the day of their destruction, nor have opened your mouth wide on the day of their distress” (Obadiah 1:12).
The objection ordinarily raised against this interpretation of Obadiah 1:10–14 is that the prophet does not speak in these verses about the destruction of the Temple. But the central subject of the prophet’s discourse is not the conquest of Jerusalem, whose principal event was the destruction of the Temple, but rather the conduct of the Edomites during that conquest. Therefore, it was not necessary for the prophet to mention the destruction of the Temple. Attention is also drawn (Cornely, Orelli, Jungerov) to the circumstance that neither in Obadiah 1:10–14 nor afterward does the prophet mention the Babylonians by name, and that, in general, the enemies of Judah in Obadiah 1:10–14 are designated by the indefinite terms sarim and nachrim (“foreigners,” “strangers”—Obadiah 1:11). This is regarded as an objection to assigning Obadiah 1:10–14 to the conquest of Jerusalem by the Chaldeans. But, with equal justification, the indefinite designation of the enemies in these verses could be regarded as an objection to any other interpretation of them. If the Chaldeans must necessarily be named, then the Syrians and the Philistines must also be named. According to Nowack, the Chaldeans are not mentioned because, by the time the book was written, they had disappeared from the stage of history.
Another explanation is also possible: the enemies were before everyone’s eyes and so well known that there was no need to identify them specifically. In any case, the relationship between Judah and Edom described in Obadiah 1:10–14 corresponds to no other historical moment as well as it does to the hostile actions of the Edomites during the capture of Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar. Therefore, the year 586, the year Jerusalem was captured, is the earliest date before which the Book of Obadiah could not have appeared (terminus a quo).
In addition to the evidence contained in the Book of Obadiah itself, another consideration has long been brought forward in determining the date of its origin, as noted above: the close similarity between Obadiah’s vision concerning Edom and Jeremiah’s prophecy concerning the same people (Jeremiah 49:1).
The question of the relationship between the Book of Obadiah and Jeremiah 49 is resolved in very different ways. It follows that the relationship between the biblical passages under consideration is difficult to establish with complete certainty. The most reasonable explanation of the similarity between the Book of Obadiah and Jeremiah 49 appears to be the supposition that both depend on a third, more ancient source. In any case, the disputed fact of the close similarity between the Book of Obadiah and Jeremiah 49, especially in view of the greater clarity of the evidence contained in the Book of Obadiah itself, cannot contradict the conclusion that the Book of Obadiah was written after the destruction of Jerusalem. In the absence of clear evidence, it is impossible to establish with certainty the precise point in the post-Exilic period to which the composition of the Book of Obadiah should be assigned. If the completion of the canon is to be assigned to the period of Ezra and Nehemiah, then this time—that is, the middle of the fifth century before Christ—constitutes the terminus ad quem of the Book of Obadiah. A further indication can be drawn from the contents of the book. The prophet speaks of Edom’s final destruction as something still in the future. But, by analogy with other prophetic predictions, it should be assumed that Obadiah takes the immediate occasion for his discourse about Edom’s future fate from circumstances contemporary with him. Such an occasion would have been some devastation of Idumea that took place during his lifetime. The prophet regards this devastation as a forewarning and an image of the final destruction that awaits Edom in the future. During the period of the Babylonians’ advance and, subsequently, that of the Persians, Idumea could have been devastated repeatedly, since it would inevitably have been drawn into the wars of the Babylonians and Persians against Egypt. In addition, from the sixth century onward, Idumea also began to suffer from attacks from the south, from the Arabs, who eventually drove the Edomites completely out of their territory and took possession of Tyre in 312. One of the attacks by Arab nomadic tribes against Idumea could have served as the occasion for Obadiah’s discourse.
The Book of the Prophet Obadiah thus belonged to the section of prophecy concerning the fate of foreign nations. Alongside the great world monarchies—Assyria, Babylon, and Egypt—Edom is a people to whom the prophets turned their attention more frequently (compare Isaiah 21:11–12; 34:5–6; 63:1; Jeremiah 49:7–22; Ezekiel 25:12–14; 35 and others). This insignificant people, related to the Jews by descent, proud of the wisdom for which it had long been renowned, and trusting in the inaccessibility of the rocks on which it had settled, had always been one of the most cruel and implacable enemies of the house of Judah. Consequently, for the prophets, Edom represents a world hostile to the Kingdom of God, and the thought of the triumph of this Kingdom is associated in their writings with the defeat of Edom and judgment against it (Isaiah 34:1; 63:1). In revealing Edom’s future fate, Obadiah follows the other prophets in general. The contents of the book contain no particular distinctive features. Blessed Jerome, characterizing the Book of Obadiah, rightly observes: “He is a minor prophet in the number of verses, not in the substance of his thoughts.” In its presentation, biblical scholars note the force of expression, liveliness, and purity of the Hebrew language (Cheyne, Selbie, Baudissin). Condamin also points out, not without reason, that throughout the entire book Obadiah employs the same technique of using synonymous expressions and even repeating the same words (Obadiah 1:1–3, 11–14, 17–18). In addition, Condamin finds in the Book of Obadiah a strophic structure maintained from beginning to end. These features of the book’s presentation, as well as the development of its contents, provide grounds for rejecting the attempts of more recent authors (Nowack, Marti, Wellhausen) to deny the unity of the Book of Obadiah and divide it into sections belonging to different writers and different periods.
Source: Translated by John Sanidopoulos.
